* WGs marked with an * asterisk has had at least one new draft made available during the last 5 days

Spring Status Pages

Source Packet Routing in Networking (Active WG)
Rtg Area: Alia Atlas, Alvaro Retana, Deborah Brungard | 2013-Oct-25 —  
Chairs
 
 


IETF-100 spring minutes

Session 2017-11-15 1520-1650: Olivia - Audio stream - spring chatroom

Minutes

minutes-100-spring-00 minutes



          draft-bryant-mpls-unified-ip-sr-03
          Jeff Tantsura
          
          Keyur: fairly simple draft, I like it
          
          
          draft-xu-mpls-unified-source-routing-instruction-04
          Xiaohu Xu
          
          Discussion on both drafts
          
          Adrian F. peace treaty has been signed. strategy for unified approach
          being worked through
          
          Xiaohu: I was not in that meeting
          
          Ahmed: This belongs in SPRING, not in MPLS
          
          Jeff T.: Does not matter where. ADs to decide.
          
          Alvaro (as AD): would personally like to see it here in SPRING but this
          has already been discussed between the chairs
          Should nevertheless be decided based on future merged draft, though I
          still think this should be in SPRING
          
          Wim: we should involve all uthors in the discussion
          
          Adrian: Don't care where, both groups should nevertheless be involved
          
          Loa: both documents are currently in Canddidate for Adoption state in
          MPLS. Also 7510 was developed in MPLS.
          
          Bruno: 7510 is not mpls specific in fact
          
          Adrian: true but our focus is mpls
          
          Wim: 7510 would not work for VXLAN
          
          Bruno: true
          
          Xiaohu: no strong opinion regarding which WG owns this
          
          Loa: But you have requested adoption in mpls
          
          Martin: we will not adopt one document in a WG and the other in the
          other WG
          
          Bruno: when will new (merged) document be ready?
          
          Adrian: best case 4 weeks
          
          Himanshu: preference for SPRING to be the home
          
          Alvaro: let's wait and decide
          
          
          draft-farrel-spring-sr-domain-interconnect-01
          Adrian Farrel
          
          [missed]
          
          
          draft-clad-spring-segment-routing-service-chaining   /
          draft-dawra-idr-bgp-sr-service-chaining
          Gaurav Dawra
          
          Greg M. comparison with SFC is inapporpriate in draft. You should use
          exact same terminology.
          
          Gaurav: SFF is no different than SR forwarder
          
          ?: couldn't we just have a terminology mapping?
          
          Ahmed: may not be a 1:1 mapping
          
          ?: if you reuse SFC architecture, then it would be good to ruse same
          terminology.
          
          
          draft-cheng-spring-mpls-path-segment-00
          Liang Geng, Mach Chen
          
          Greg M.: you use both global and domaine unique. Which one is really
          intended?
          
          Liang: domain unique
          
          Greg: which goals do you have?
          
          Liang: 3 UCs we've described
          
          Dave A.: couple of interesting aspects to this draft. Interested in
          participating.
          
          ?: other solutions exist for doing at least of of these UCs
          ?: PM can be done via steering
          
          Omar: useful work but it needs to describe how transit nodes look into
          stack.
          
          draft-hegde-spring-traffic-accounting-for-sr-paths-01
          Shraddha Hegde
          
          no question taken in interest of time
          
          
          draft-dukes-sr-for-sdwan-00
          Darren Dukes
          
          Greg: for lattency and jitter, do you use live data?
          
          Darren: depends on system used at the edge
          
          Greg: how do you do detection?
          
          Darren: up to CE to decide
          
          



Generated from PyHt script /wg/spring/minutes.pyht Latest update: 24 Oct 2012 16:51 GMT -